Is the e-bike safety debate overshadowing larger road risks in the US?
Comments Off on Is the e-bike safety debate overshadowing larger road risks in the US?Source: Electrek
There has been increasing public concern over electric bicycles and other light electric vehicles in the USA. Electrek agrees that although micromobility safety does need to be addressed and improved, it highlights that cars are the most dominant threat to road safety.
Reports of reckless riding, teenage riders performing dangerous stunts and accidents involving high-powered e-bikes have raised public and media concerns about safety on the road. Critics argue that another issue is the sale of vehicles that blur the line between bicycles and motorcycles, which are used by riders travelling at speeds beyond their abilities.
Road safety: e-bikes and cars
There are questions about whether the level of attention directed at e-bikes is proportionate to the broader dangers on American roads. Recent figures cited in media reports suggest that e-bike and e-scooter incidents have accounted for approximately 135 deaths annually in the US. Meanwhile, cars are linked to around 7,000 pedestrian deaths each year and more than 40,000 total roadway fatalities annually.
It has been argued that the focus on e-bikes risks being a distraction from the larger safety issue posed by motor vehicles, such as cars, large SUVs and trucks. It is thought that micromobility is being more heavily scrutinised in America because they are newer forms of transport that appear unfamiliar or disruptive, as opposed to cars, which have been on the roads for decades.
Calls for balanced regulation
It is acknowledged by Electrek that although e-bike can be considered as safer than cars, the industry does require improvements, such as stronger regulation of high-speed electric motorcycles marketed as bicycles, better rider education, and enforcement against reckless behaviour.
Improved support for cycling can lower road fatality rates
Equally, it is argued that e-bikes could contribute to safer roads overall if they replace short car journeys.
Research from countries with established cycling infrastructure has shown that increased bicycle use can coincide with lower transport fatality rates.
It is strongly advised that policymakers should focus not only on regulating e-bikes, but also on redesigning roads, improving cycling infrastructure, and addressing the wider risks posed by car-dependent transport systems.