The invisible municipal boundaries affecting Europe’s bike share
Comments Off on The invisible municipal boundaries affecting Europe’s bike shareSource: Zag Daily
The shared-bike landscape in much of Europe can often involve a rider needing to switch from one bike and operator system to another, to continue their journey in a different municipality. The rising proportion of electric bikes in bike-share fleets makes longer journeys more possible, increasing the likelihood of these borders being crossed. Public micromobility services provider Inurba Mobility examines how sharing systems can be grown beyond municipal boundaries.
Spain-based Inurba Mobility commissioned mobility research specialists the Urban Cycling Institute to investigate the governance of metropolitan bike sharing, including speaking with those managing implementation and operation. The aim was to learn from European examples for the expansion of Spain’s bike sharing systems beyond municipal boundaries.
Different cities’ experiences
Paris took an opportunity in 2018 when contract renewal was due, to not only change the operator, but also set up a new joint authority reaching beyond just the city, which is now AGEMOB, with responsibility for shared mobility in the Greater Paris Metropolis Area.
The MEVO system which operates in the cities of Gdańsk, Gdynia and Sopot in northern Poland is overseen across 17 municipalities by the metropolitan body OMGGS, which administrates public transport matters alongside other responsibilities. This model enables smaller municipalities to join a network which would be difficult to build at a local level.
In the Finnish cities of Helsinki and Espoo, the UCI study has highlighted the critical role of the regional transport authority, HSL, which ensures clear responsibilities and regular dialogue between stakeholders including cities, operators and sponsors. A tender process currently in progress is adopting a joint procurement approach, enabling the extension of services to more than one municipality.
In Copenhagen, the UCI study showed that legal barriers were limiting public transport operators’ involvement in bike sharing, leading to the region’s authorities to fund a pilot scheme. Post-pilot, local councils needed to fund the continuing service; the next contract will include aims to ensure a strong municipal commitment from the local-level authorities.
Two German shared-mobility systems, VRNrad and Metropolradruhr, are both overseen by a metropolitan transport authority, with functionalities of the systems including integration with local transport and the ability to cross borders between German states.
The implications for Spain
Reflecting on the study, Alejandro Martín Barraza, Bid Manager and Urban Planner for Inurba Mobility, said, “There is no single formula to import. The common thread is that someone at metropolitan scale took responsibility. Contracts, funding and decision-making arrangements followed. That order matters.”
Four Spanish territories (Bizkaia, Pamplona, Valladolid and Barcelona) are already taking different approaches to expansion, with the most fragmented example being Barcelona, where the two different systems do not currently form a continuous operational network, though there are indications of a future merge.
Barraza argues that no one approach is inherently right or wrong. “The European examples matter because they show that different institutions can take responsibility, provided their mandate and the contractual framework support metropolitan coordination.”
He goes on to state that a solution is not necessarily the creation of a new organisation to oversee expansion, but possibly looking at which existing body could take on the responsibility, with consideration for what mandate, resources and agreements it would need. A key aspect is that the ability of other municipalities to join must be considered from the outset.
User benefits
Streamlined expansion of bike-sharing services offers advantages including simpler pricing structures, single apps, and easier hire and return of vehicles. Expansion also enables greater integration with existing public transport networks, further enhancing the user experience, while helping a region achieve sustainable mobility goals.